Home NFL Passing the Torch: The Evolution of NFL Greatness from Montana to Mahomes

Passing the Torch: The Evolution of NFL Greatness from Montana to Mahomes

Comparing the First Five Seasons

by Riley Baines
First 5 Seasons in the NFL as a Starter - Patrick Mahomes - Tom Brady - Joe Montana

Patrick Mahomes vs Tom Brady vs Joe Montana

In the illustrious history of the National Football League (NFL), the quarterback position has not only been a pivotal role but has witnessed an evolution of talent that redefines the parameters of greatness. From Joe Montana’s poised precision in the 1980s to Tom Brady’s unmatched dominance in the 21st century, and now, the meteoric rise of Patrick Mahomes. Each quarterback has been a product of his era and has in turn, reshaped the expectations of the position.

Joe Montana:

Joe Montana First Five Seasons Stats: 17,371 passing yards, 117 touchdowns, 58 interceptions, 93.1 passer rating, 63.2 completion percentage, 49-22-0 record

Joe Montana, dubbed “Joe Cool,” led the San Francisco 49ers to four Super Bowl titles, a feat that in itself is a testament to his prowess. In his first five seasons, Montana showcased an innate ability to remain calm under pressure and deliver in the most crucial moments. His finesse and accuracy set the standard for what it meant to be an elite quarterback during his era.


Tom Brady:

Tom Brady First Five Seasons Stats: 18,029 passing yards, 123 touchdowns, 66 interceptions, 88.5 passer rating, 61.9 completion percentage, 58-20-0 record

Then came Tom Brady, the embodiment of perseverance. Overlooked and drafted 199th overall, no one could’ve predicted that the New England Patriots would land one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time. Brady’s commitment to excellence, adaptability, and unparalleled leadership led him to seven Super Bowl titles, with six coming from the Patriots. In his initial years, Brady combined Montana’s cool-headedness with a competitive fire that pushed the boundaries of the quarterback position.


Patrick Mahomes:

Patrick Mahomes First Five Seasons Stats: 23,957 passing yards, 192 touchdowns, 48 interceptions, 106.0 passer rating, 66.5 completion percentage, 63-16-0 record

Now, the NFL finds itself captivated by the enigma that is Patrick Mahomes. With a blend of raw talent, athleticism, and a unique ability to improvise, Mahomes has redefined what is possible on the football field. His no-look passes and off-the-cuff plays have made highlight reels more times than one can count. In his first five seasons, Mahomes has already secured two Super Bowl rings, and two MVP awards, and has shattered numerous passing records. His trajectory points towards not just greatness, but potential supremacy.


However, with greatness comes the weight of expectations. As Montana and Brady have set the bar, Mahomes now faces the challenge of not just reaching those heights but possibly surpassing them. Longevity, consistency, and the ability to adapt will be key in his pursuit of being acknowledged as the greatest quarterback of all time.

The NFL, with its rich history and evolution, is a testament to the changing nature of the game. From Montana’s finesse to Brady’s meticulous approach and Mahomes’ flamboyance, the league has witnessed a transformative journey. One thing is for certain, as the torch gets passed from one legend to another, fans worldwide are treated to an unparalleled spectacle of talent, determination, and sheer will to win.

For the most up-to-date NFL content including NFL top 10s, NFL tier lists, NFL rankings & NFL Records, follow me on Instagram @sogfootball! I’m always open for debate.

Related Articles

Leave a Comment