Best Quarterbacks in NFL History Tier List

This is an all-time NFL ranking for the best Quarterbacks ever ranked in tiers. From record-setting passing yards to clutch performances in critical moments, every quarterback in this ranking has left an indelible mark on the game of football.

Will you agree with this list? Probably not. But I will be looking at each Quarterbacks overall talent plus career accomplishments & accolades. Welcome to a definitive exploration of the greatest quarterbacks to ever grace the NFL.

TIER 6: 

Len Dawson

Len Dawson, a pioneer of the AFL-NFL merger era, left an indelible mark on the quarterback position with his precision passing and calm demeanor under pressure. With over 28,000 career passing yards and 239 touchdown passes, Dawson’s statistical prowess speaks volumes about his mastery of the game. However, his crowning achievement came in Super Bowl IV, where he led the Kansas City Chiefs to victory over the Minnesota Vikings, earning the game’s MVP title and solidifying his place in football history. Dawson’s legacy extends beyond his on-field accomplishments; he was a consummate leader and a model of consistency, paving the way for future generations of quarterbacks with his enduring impact on the sport.

Joe Namath

Joe Namath, affectionately known as “Broadway Joe,” etched his name in NFL lore with his charismatic persona and bold playing style. While his career statistics may not rival some of his peers, Namath’s impact transcended numbers. His most iconic moment came in Super Bowl III, where he famously guaranteed victory for his underdog New York Jets against the heavily favored Baltimore Colts. True to his word, Namath delivered, leading the Jets to a historic upset and earning MVP honors in the process. Beyond his on-field achievements, Namath’s influence extended off the gridiron, shaping the image of the modern quarterback as a cultural icon and paving the way for the NFL’s ascension into mainstream entertainment.

Donovan McNabb

Over his career, McNabb amassed over 37,000 passing yards and nearly 250 touchdown passes, showcasing his prowess as a prolific passer. Notably, he is one of the very few quarterbacks in NFL history to have thrown for over 30,000 yards and rushed for over 3,000 yards in his career, highlighting his rare dual-threat abilities. McNabb’s impact extended far beyond statistics, as he led the Philadelphia Eagles to unprecedented success during his tenure. His ability to orchestrate high-powered offenses was on full display in iconic moments like the “4th and 26” conversion against the Green Bay Packers in the 2003 NFC Divisional Playoff game, where McNabb’s clutch play propelled the Eagles to a dramatic comeback victory. Additionally, his leadership and resilience were evident in his five NFC Championship game appearances and Super Bowl XXXIX berth, cementing his status as a franchise cornerstone and one of the most revered quarterbacks of his generation.

Ken Stabler

Ken Stabler, affectionately known as “The Snake,” was a quarterback whose impact reverberated throughout the NFL during the 1970s. While his career statistics are impressive with over 27,000 passing yards and 194 touchdown passes, Stabler’s true greatness lay in his ability to thrive in clutch moments. He was the epitome of a “gunslinger,” known for his fearless playmaking and uncanny ability to lead game-winning drives. Stabler’s most iconic moment came in Super Bowl XI when he led the Oakland Raiders to a decisive victory over the Minnesota Vikings, earning MVP honors for his stellar performance. Beyond the numbers, Stabler’s swagger and charisma endeared him to fans and solidified his legacy as one of the most iconic quarterbacks of his era.

Sid Luckman

Sid Luckman’s impact on the NFL cannot be overstated, as he revolutionized the quarterback position during his tenure with the Chicago Bears in the 1940s. While his career statistics may not stand out by today’s standards, Luckman’s innovative passing game transformed offensive strategies and paved the way for the modern quarterback. He led the Bears to four NFL Championships and set numerous passing records during his career, including throwing seven touchdown passes in a single game—a feat that stood unmatched for over 70 years. Luckman’s contributions to the game extended far beyond his statistics, as he remains a legendary figure in NFL history and a trailblazer for future generations of quarterbacks.

Norm Van Brocklin

Norm Van Brocklin, often referred to as “The Dutchman,” left an indelible mark on the NFL as one of the most prolific passers of his era. With over 23,000 career passing yards and 173 touchdown passes, Van Brocklin’s statistics speak to his undeniable talent as a quarterback. However, his true greatness was exemplified by his remarkable performance in the 1951 NFL Championship Game, where he led the Los Angeles Rams to victory with an unprecedented 554 passing yards—a record that still stands today. Van Brocklin’s precision passing, leadership, and competitive spirit solidified his legacy as one of the game’s all-time greats, earning him induction into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1971.

Steve McNair

Steve McNair, affectionately known as “Air McNair,” was a dynamic quarterback whose impact on the NFL was felt both on and off the field. With over 31,000 career passing yards and 174 touchdown passes, McNair’s statistical achievements reflect his talent as a passer. However, it was his toughness, resilience, and ability to make plays under pressure that truly set him apart. McNair’s most memorable moment came during the 1999 season when he led the Tennessee Titans to the Super Bowl, narrowly falling short in a thrilling game against the St. Louis Rams. Throughout his career, McNair’s leadership and determination inspired teammates and fans alike, leaving an enduring legacy as one of the most respected quarterbacks in NFL history.

Cam Newton

Cam Newton, known for his dual-threat abilities and unparalleled athleticism, made a significant impact on the NFL during his career. With over 31,000 passing yards and 190 touchdown passes, along with over 5,000 rushing yards and 70 rushing touchdowns, Newton’s statistics alone demonstrate his versatility and impact on the game. However, it was his 2015 MVP season that truly showcased his dominance, leading the Carolina Panthers to a 15-1 record and a Super Bowl appearance. Newton’s unique style of play, highlighted by his powerful arm and elusive running ability, redefined the quarterback position and inspired a new generation of mobile quarterbacks. While injuries and team changes may have affected his later years in the league, Newton’s legacy as a transformative figure in NFL history remains undisputed.

TIER 5: 

Philip Rivers

Philip Rivers, known for his fiery competitiveness and consistent play, established himself as one of the most prolific passers in NFL history. With over 63,000 career passing yards and 421 touchdown passes, Rivers ranks among the top quarterbacks in league history statistically. His remarkable durability and consecutive starts streak reflect his toughness and dedication to the game. While he never won a Super Bowl, Rivers’ leadership and ability to lead his teams to the playoffs on multiple occasions demonstrate his impact on the field. Beyond his on-field accomplishments, Rivers’ passion for the game and his colorful personality endeared him to fans and teammates alike, solidifying his legacy as one of the most respected quarterbacks of his era.

Russell Wilson

Russell Wilson, often hailed for his exceptional leadership and playmaking abilities, has carved out a remarkable career as one of the most dynamic quarterbacks in the NFL. With over 30,000 career passing yards and 270 touchdown passes, Wilson’s statistical prowess underscores his impact on the game. However, it’s his ability to extend plays with his legs and deliver clutch performances in critical moments that truly sets him apart. Wilson’s Super Bowl victory in 2014, along with multiple playoff appearances, showcases his ability to lead his team to success on the grandest stage. Beyond his on-field achievements, Wilson’s dedication to community service and his unwavering commitment to excellence have earned him respect both on and off the field, solidifying his legacy as one of the premier quarterbacks of his generation.

Dan Fouts

Matt Ryan

Matt Ryan, widely respected for his consistency and leadership, has solidified his place among the NFL’s elite quarterbacks. With over 55,000 career passing yards and 350 touchdown passes, Ryan’s statistical accomplishments highlight his proficiency as a passer. His standout season in 2016, which culminated in winning the NFL MVP award, showcased his ability to elevate his play to an elite level. Despite the 28-3 blunder, it still goes down as one of the best seasons for any Quarterback in NFL history.

Matthew Stafford

Matthew Stafford, recognized for his arm strength and clutch performances, has emerged as one of the most talented quarterbacks in the NFL. With over 50,000 career passing yards and 300 touchdown passes, Stafford’s statistical achievements underscore his proficiency as a passer. Known for his ability to orchestrate game-winning drives, Stafford has earned a reputation as a resilient and fearless competitor. His leadership both on and off the field has been instrumental in guiding the Detroit Lions through various challenges, and came to fruition when he led the Rams to a Super Bowl victory in only his first season with the team.

Kurt Warner

Kurt Warner, celebrated for his remarkable journey from grocery store clerk to NFL MVP, remains one of the most inspirational figures in football history. With over 32,000 career passing yards and 208 touchdown passes, Warner’s statistical achievements highlight his exceptional talent as a quarterback. His Cinderella story reached its pinnacle during the “Greatest Show on Turf” era with the St. Louis Rams, where Warner led the team to victory in Super Bowl XXXIV and earned MVP honors.

Sammy Baugh

Sammy Baugh, often hailed as one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time, revolutionized the game with his exceptional passing skills and versatility. With over 21,000 career passing yards and 187 touchdown passes, Baugh’s statistical achievements were remarkable for his era. He was a true pioneer, introducing innovations such as the forward pass and the role of the quarterback as a primary passer rather than just a blocker or runner. Baugh’s impact extended beyond the quarterback position; he was also a standout punter and defensive back, showcasing his versatility and athleticism.

Jim Kelly

Jim Kelly, renowned for his toughness, leadership, and competitive spirit, is widely regarded as one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history. With over 35,000 career passing yards and 237 touchdown passes, Kelly’s statistical achievements underscore his prowess as a passer. He was the heart and soul of the Buffalo Bills during their dominant run in the 1990s, leading the team to four consecutive Super Bowl appearances—an unprecedented feat. Despite facing adversity both on and off the field, including a well-documented battle with cancer, Kelly’s resilience and determination never wavered.

TIER 4: 

Bart Starr

Bart Starr, a true legend of the game, epitomized excellence and grace both on and off the field. With over 24,000 career passing yards and 152 touchdown passes, Starr’s statistical achievements reflect his skill as a quarterback. However, it was his remarkable leadership and poise under pressure that truly set him apart. Starr’s unparalleled success with the Green Bay Packers, including leading the team to five NFL championships and victories in the first two Super Bowls, cemented his status as one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time.

Troy Aikman

Troy Aikman, a cornerstone of the Dallas Cowboys’ dynasty in the 1990s, solidified his place among the NFL’s elite quarterbacks with his precision passing and leadership on the field. With over 32,000 career passing yards and 165 touchdown passes, Aikman’s statistical achievements are a testament to his talent and consistency. He orchestrated one of the most dominant eras in Cowboys’ history, leading the team to three Super Bowl victories in four years. Aikman’s ability to thrive under pressure and deliver in crucial moments earned him the respect of teammates and opponents alike.

Ben Roethlisberger

Ben Roethlisberger, revered for his toughness and clutch performances, has left an indelible mark on the NFL as one of the premier quarterbacks of his era. With over 64,000 career passing yards and 418 touchdown passes, Roethlisberger’s statistical achievements highlight his prolific career. He led the Pittsburgh Steelers to two Super Bowl victories and consistently guided the team to playoff contention throughout his tenure. Roethlisberger’s ability to extend plays with his size and strength, combined with his knack for delivering in critical moments, earned him the admiration of fans and the respect of his peers.

Warren Moon

Warren Moon, a trailblazer in the NFL, showcased remarkable talent and resilience throughout his illustrious career. With over 49,000 career passing yards and 291 touchdown passes, Moon’s statistical achievements underscore his excellence as a quarterback. Despite facing obstacles early in his career due to racial bias, Moon persevered and became a dominant force in professional football. His success in both the CFL and NFL, coupled with his groundbreaking achievements as an African American quarterback, paved the way for future generations of players.

Fran Tarkenton

Fran Tarkenton, known for his electrifying style of play and unparalleled improvisational skills, redefined the quarterback position during his illustrious career. With over 47,000 career passing yards and 342 touchdown passes, Tarkenton’s statistical achievements speak to his dominance as a passer. He revolutionized the game with his ability to extend plays and make something out of nothing, earning him the nickname “The Scrambler.” Tarkenton’s success with both the Minnesota Vikings and New York Giants, including multiple Pro Bowl selections and an MVP award, solidified his status as one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time.

Eli Manning

Eli Manning, a two-time Super Bowl MVP and one of the most clutch quarterbacks in NFL history, has left an enduring legacy on the game. With over 57,000 career passing yards and 366 touchdown passes, Manning’s statistical achievements highlight his prolific career. He led the New York Giants to two improbable Super Bowl victories over the New England Patriots, solidifying his reputation as a big-game performer. Manning’s calm demeanor under pressure and ability to deliver in critical moments endeared him to fans and teammates alike.

Terry Bradshaw

Terry Bradshaw, a four-time Super Bowl champion and Hall of Famer, stands as one of the most accomplished quarterbacks in NFL history. With over 27,000 career passing yards and 212 touchdown passes, Bradshaw’s statistical achievements underscore his impact on the game. He led the Pittsburgh Steelers to unprecedented success in the 1970s, earning MVP honors in two of their Super Bowl victories. Bradshaw’s powerful arm and ability to thrive in pressure-packed situations made him a feared opponent on the field.

TIER 3: 

John Elway

John Elway, a two-time Super Bowl champion and Hall of Famer, is revered as one of the most iconic quarterbacks in NFL history. With over 51,000 career passing yards and 300 touchdown passes, Elway’s statistical achievements highlight his exceptional talent as a passer. He was known for his remarkable arm strength, athleticism, and ability to lead game-winning drives. Elway’s leadership on the field was instrumental in transforming the Denver Broncos into perennial contenders during his tenure. His legendary performances in Super Bowls XXXII and XXXIII solidified his status as one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time.

Otto Graham

Otto Graham, a trailblazing quarterback and Hall of Famer, forever changed the landscape of professional football during his illustrious career. While exact statistics from his era may not reflect his full impact, Graham’s dominance on the field was unquestionable. He led the Cleveland Browns to an unprecedented 10 championship games in 10 seasons, winning seven of them. Graham’s exceptional leadership, accuracy, and versatility set the standard for future generations of quarterbacks. His legacy as a true pioneer of the game and one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history endures through his numerous records, championships, and lasting impact on the sport.

Roger Staubach

Roger Staubach, affectionately known as “Captain Comeback,” is celebrated as one of the most clutch quarterbacks in NFL history. With over 22,000 career passing yards and 153 touchdown passes, Staubach’s statistical achievements reflect his excellence as a passer. He led the Dallas Cowboys to two Super Bowl victories and earned MVP honors in Super Bowl VI. Staubach’s remarkable ability to rally his team to victory in the closing moments of games earned him a reputation as a legendary leader and competitor.

Johnny Unitas

Johnny Unitas, often referred to as “Johnny U,” is revered as one of the greatest quarterbacks to ever play the game. With over 40,000 career passing yards and 290 touchdown passes, Unitas’ statistical achievements are a testament to his exceptional talent as a passer. He revolutionized the quarterback position with his innovative passing techniques and leadership on the field. Unitas’ most memorable moments came with the Baltimore Colts, including leading the team to victory in Super Bowl V and his legendary performance in the 1958 NFL Championship Game, often referred to as “The Greatest Game Ever Played.”

Brett Favre

Brett Favre, known for his rocket arm, durability, and fearless playing style, is widely regarded as one of the most exciting quarterbacks in NFL history. With over 71,000 career passing yards and 508 touchdown passes, Favre’s statistical achievements are staggering, making him one of the most prolific passers of all time. He was a three-time NFL MVP and led the Green Bay Packers to victory in Super Bowl XXXI. Favre’s iconic moments on the field, including his record streak of 297 consecutive starts, showcased his toughness and competitive spirit.

Steve Young

Steve Young, a Hall of Fame quarterback, is celebrated for his electrifying playing style and remarkable achievements on the field. With over 33,000 career passing yards and 232 touchdown passes, Young’s statistical accomplishments underscore his excellence as a quarterback. He was a two-time NFL MVP and led the San Francisco 49ers to victory in Super Bowl XXIX, earning Super Bowl MVP honors. Young’s ability to both throw accurately and run with speed and agility revolutionized the quarterback position, paving the way for the dual-threat quarterbacks of today.

TIER 2: 

Patrick Mahomes

Patrick Mahomes, widely regarded as one of the most talented quarterbacks in NFL history, has quickly risen to prominence with his electrifying playing style and remarkable achievements on the field. With two Super Bowl victories under his belt, both of which he earned Super Bowl MVP honors, Mahomes has cemented his status as a clutch performer on the biggest stage. His ability to make awe-inspiring throws from impossible angles and his uncanny knack for leading his team to victory have set him apart as a transcendent talent in the league. Mahomes is on pace to potentially surpass Tom Brady’s records and has already established himself as one of the most exciting and impactful players in NFL history.

Peyton Manning

Peyton Manning, a true icon of the game, is widely regarded as one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history. With two Super Bowl victories under his belt, including one Super Bowl MVP honor, Manning has solidified his legacy as a clutch performer on the biggest stage. His remarkable football IQ, unmatched work ethic, and unparalleled leadership abilities set him apart as a transcendent talent in the league. Manning’s illustrious career saw him break numerous records, and his impact on the game extends far beyond his statistical achievements. From his precision passing to his ability to command the field, Manning’s influence on the quarterback position and the NFL as a whole is undeniable, earning him a place among the all-time greats. If the season ended in week 17, he would be regarded as the best Quarterback in NFL history.

Joe Montana

Joe Montana, often referred to as “Joe Cool,” is widely recognized as one of the greatest quarterbacks to ever play the game. With four Super Bowl victories to his name, including three Super Bowl MVP awards, Montana’s legacy as a clutch performer on the biggest stage is unparalleled. That is especially apparent considering he is 4 for 4 in Super Bowl action. His ability to lead his teams to victory in pressure-packed situations earned him the reputation as one of the most clutch quarterbacks in NFL history. Montana’s pinpoint accuracy, football IQ, and ability to thrive in high-pressure situations set the standard for excellence at the quarterback position.

Drew Brees

Drew Brees, is widely regarded as one of the most prolific passers in NFL history. With a Super Bowl victory to his name, along with numerous passing records, Brees’ impact on the game is undeniable. His precision passing, football IQ, and leadership on and off the field have earned him the respect of teammates, opponents, and fans alike. Brees’ ability to dissect defenses and deliver pinpoint throws has set him apart as one of the elite quarterbacks of his era. It’s an absolute travesty that he was never awarded an MVP over his career.

Aaron Rodgers

Aaron Rodgers, often hailed as one of the most talented quarterbacks of his generation, has left an indelible mark on the NFL with his unparalleled skillset and remarkable achievements on the field. With a Super Bowl victory, multiple NFL MVP awards, and numerous passing records, Rodgers’ impact on the game is undeniable. His combination of arm strength, accuracy, and mobility make him a threat to opposing defenses on every snap. Rodgers’ ability to deliver in clutch moments and lead his team to victory has solidified his status as one of the premier quarterbacks in NFL history. If he can find playoff success with the lowly Jets in 2024, he would make a jump in the argument for best Quarterback ever.

Dan Marino

Dan Marino, a legendary figure in NFL history, is widely revered as one of the greatest quarterbacks to ever grace the gridiron. Despite never winning a Super Bowl, Marino’s impact on the game is undeniable. With over 61,000 career passing yards and 420 touchdown passes, Marino’s statistical achievements stand as a testament to his unparalleled talent as a passer. His quick release, pinpoint accuracy, and ability to read defenses made him a nightmare for opposing defenses. Marino’s record-breaking performances and numerous accolades, including being named NFL MVP in 1984, solidify his status as one of the elite quarterbacks of his era and of all-time.

TIER 1: THE GOAT

Tom Brady

Tom Brady’s legacy as the greatest quarterback of all time transcends mere statistics and accolades; it’s a narrative of unparalleled success, sustained excellence, and a relentless pursuit of greatness. His seven Super Bowl victories stand as a testament to his unrivaled ability to lead his teams to the ultimate triumph on football’s biggest stage. What sets Brady apart is not just his incredible skill as a passer, but his unparalleled mental toughness, leadership, and ability to elevate the performance of those around him. His career is defined by his ability to perform at an elite level year after year, regardless of the challenges he faced.

Moreover, Brady’s success with multiple teams further solidifies his claim to greatness. His ability to transition from the New England Patriots to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and immediately lead them to a Super Bowl victory speaks volumes about his adaptability and football IQ. Throughout his career, Brady has consistently defied the odds, silenced doubters, and rewritten the record books, setting new standards for excellence at the quarterback position.

Beyond the numbers and championships, Brady’s impact on the game of football is immeasurable. He’s become a symbol of perseverance, determination, and the relentless pursuit of excellence. His work ethic, discipline, and commitment to his craft serve as an inspiration to athletes across all sports, demonstrating that with hard work and dedication, anything is possible.

Best Quarterbacks in NFL History Tier List

Conclusion

In conclusion, the list of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history is a testament to the rich tapestry of talent, skill, and determination that has graced the gridiron over the years. From pioneers like Sammy Baugh and Otto Graham to modern-day legends like Tom Brady and Patrick Mahomes, each quarterback has made history.

While debates may rage on about the rankings and accolades, one thing remains clear: the legacy of these quarterbacks will endure for generations to come, shaping the future of football.

For the most up-to-date NFL content, follow me on Instagram at @sogfootball! I’m always open for debate.