Most Career Rushing Yards by an Indianapolis Colts Player

Most Career Rushing Yards by an Indianapolis Colts Player

The Indianapolis Colts’ rushing history is rich with legends who laid the groundwork for the franchise’s success, from Hall of Famers like Edgerrin James to modern-day stars like Jonathan Taylor. Edgerrin James’ 9,226 rushing yards remain a gold standard for the franchise, and his explosive career perfectly complemented Peyton Manning’s aerial assault. But the Colts have always had a strong ground game, thanks to players like Marshall Faulk, Lydell Mitchell, and even a surprise contributor like Tom Matte.

What makes the Colts’ rushing history so special is its blend of eras and styles — from the early workhorse running backs like Alan Ameche to the dual-threat brilliance of Jonathan Taylor. Whether it’s bruising power, finesse, or speed, each of these backs has contributed to one of the NFL’s most dynamic rushing legacies.

TOP 10 LIST

10. Randy McMillan – 3,876 Yards
A steady contributor during the mid-1980s, McMillan powered through defenses with an old-school running style.

9. Alan Ameche – 4,045 Yards
Known as “The Horse,” Ameche scored the winning TD in the 1958 NFL Championship and helped define the Colts’ early era.

8. Joseph Addai – 4,453 Yards
Part of the Colts’ Super Bowl XLI run, Addai was a dual-threat back who brought vision and finesse to the backfield.

7. Tom Matte – 4,646 Yards
A true Colts ironman, Matte was versatile enough to run, catch, and even play emergency quarterback in the ’60s.

6. Lenny Moore – 5,174 Yards
More than just a rusher, Moore was a dynamic all-purpose weapon who helped Baltimore dominate in the pre-merger era.

5. Eric Dickerson – 5,194 Yards
While more famous for his time with the Rams, Dickerson still managed over 5,000 yards as a Colt, bringing Hall of Fame clout to Indy.

4. Marshall Faulk – 5,320 Yards
Before “The Greatest Show on Turf,” Faulk was dazzling Colts fans with his dual-threat brilliance as a rookie phenom.

3. Lydell Mitchell – 5,487 Yards
A go-to workhorse in the ’70s, Mitchell delivered consistency and reliability as the Colts transitioned eras.

2. Jonathan Taylor – 6,013 Yards
Taylor exploded onto the scene and quickly shot up the list. His blend of power, speed, and vision has made him one of the NFL’s elite backs.

1. Edgerrin James – 9,226 Yards
The king of Colts rushing. “Edge” was the perfect complement to Peyton Manning’s offense, delivering two rushing titles and a Hall of Fame career.

The Colts’ all-time rushing leaders from Edgerrin James to Randy McMillan

Top 50 Career Rushing Performances in Colts History

This list highlights every Colts player to rush for 536 or more yards with the franchise — from Hall of Fame legends to underappreciated grinders.

 From Edgerrin James’ explosive dominance to Jonathan Taylor’s ongoing ascent, the Colts’ rushing history reflects excellence across generations. Whether you grew up watching Ameche or Taylor, this franchise has always had a game-changer in the backfield.

FAQ SECTION

Who is the all-time rushing leader for the Colts?
Edgerrin James leads the way with 9,226 rushing yards in a Colts uniform.

Is Jonathan Taylor still active?
Yes, Jonathan Taylor is still active and ranked 2nd on the list with 6,013 yards and counting.

Which Hall of Famers appear on this list?
Hall of Famers Edgerrin James, Marshall Faulk, Eric Dickerson, and Lenny Moore all made the top 10.

Want more records and rankings like this?
📲 Follow @sogfootball on Instagram — daily debates and stat drops.
🔗 Browse all NFL Records and Tier Lists on the site here.